Skip to content
eatmundo/Compare

Bread and Butter Pudding vs Classic St. Louis Gooey Butter Cake

See how these two dishes stack up, ingredient by ingredient.

Two questions, two answers

Same ingredients?
63%ingredients in common
Same technique?
No
Bread and Butter PuddingCustard & puddingClassic St. Louis Gooey Butter CakeCake

Both desserts share butter, eggs, sugar, milk and vanilla, yet put them to very different work. In the bread and butter pudding, eggs, milk, cream, sugar and vanilla form a custard that soaks layers of buttered stale bread and raisins, baking up golden and puffed with a creamy, slightly wobbly centre and a warm hint of nutmeg. The gooey butter cake uses melted butter twice, in a pressed flour base and in a rich cream cheese and powdered sugar topping that bakes set yet gooey. One is soft and custardy; the other dense, sweet and indulgent.

Prep time, calories & servings

Bread and Butter Pudding
35 min
A relaxed effort
640 kcal
Feast-worthy
4 servings
Great for the family
Classic St. Louis Gooey Butter Cake
40 min
A relaxed effort
380 kcal
Nicely balanced
16 servings
Feeds a crowd

What they have in common

What's different

Only in Bread and Butter Pudding
  • Nutmeg
  • Raisin
  • Cream
  • Bread
Only in Classic St. Louis Gooey Butter Cake
  • Cream cheese
  • Powdered sugar

Other counterparts