eatmundo/Compare

Bread and Butter Pudding vs Classic St. Louis Gooey Butter Cake

See how these two dishes stack up, ingredient by ingredient.

Bread and Butter Pudding relies on the structural transformation of soaked bread to create a custard-like, comforting texture, accented by warm nutmeg and fruit. In contrast, the Classic St. Louis Gooey Butter Cake utilizes a base of cream cheese and powdered sugar to achieve its signature dense, sugary, and decadent top layer. While both share a foundational base of milk, eggs, and butter, the former emphasizes a soft, bread-based soak while the latter focuses on a rich, buttery, and firm-yet-gooey interior.

Prep time, calories & servings

Bread and Butter Pudding
⏱ 20 min
Quicker than a pizza delivery
πŸ”₯ 400 kcal
Nicely balanced
🍽 4 servings
Great for the family
Classic St. Louis Gooey Butter Cake
⏱ 20 min
Quicker than a pizza delivery
πŸ”₯ 450 kcal
Hearty helping
🍽 4 servings
Great for the family

What they have in common

Milk
Milk
Vanilla
Vanilla
Sugar
Sugar
Butter
Butter
Egg
Egg

What's different

Only in Bread and Butter Pudding
  • Nutmeg
  • Raisin
  • Cream
  • Bread
Only in Classic St. Louis Gooey Butter Cake
  • Cream cheese
  • Powdered sugar