eatmundo/Compare

Hachis Parmentier: Classic French Shepherd's Pie vs Hearty Cottage Pie with Creamy Potato Topping

See how these two dishes stack up, ingredient by ingredient.

Hachis Parmentier and Cottage Pie rely on a shared foundation of ground beef and root vegetables, yet their flavor profiles diverge through distinct aromatics and enrichments. The Hachis Parmentier uses a refined approach, incorporating nutmeg and a Gruyere-enriched potato crust for a velvety, nuanced finish. Conversely, Cottage Pie leans into savory, umami-rich depths with Worcestershire sauce and a mirepoix of celery, resulting in a robust, rustic texture. These dishes offer two unique culinary expressions of comfort through contrasting seasoning techniques and dairy finishing methods.

Prep time, calories & servings

Hachis Parmentier: Classic French Shepherd's Pie
40 min
A relaxed effort
🔥 600 kcal
Hearty helping
🍽 4 servings
Great for the family
Hearty Cottage Pie with Creamy Potato Topping
60 min
A great way to spend your free time
🔥 650 kcal
Feast-worthy
🍽 4 servings
Great for the family

What they have in common

Garlic
Garlic
Olive oil
Olive oil
Milk
Milk
Potato
Potato
Carrot
Carrot
Tomato paste
Tomato paste
Thyme
Thyme
Onion
Onion
Butter
Butter
Black pepper
Pepper
Ground beef
Ground beef
Beef broth
Beef stock

What's different

Only in Hachis Parmentier: Classic French Shepherd's Pie
  • Bay leaf
  • Nutmeg
  • Gruyere cheese
  • Egg yolk
Only in Hearty Cottage Pie with Creamy Potato Topping
  • Worcestershire sauce
  • Parmesan
  • Celery