Skip to content
eatmundo/Compare

Creamy New England Clam Chowder vs Cullen Skink (Traditional Scottish Smoked Haddock Soup)

See how these two dishes stack up, ingredient by ingredient.

Two questions, two answers

Same ingredients?
60%ingredients in common
Same technique?
Yes
Creamy New England Clam ChowderSoupCullen SkinkSoup

Both soups build on milk, cream, butter, potato and onion, yet they reach richness by different routes. The clam chowder starts with crisp bacon and its fat, softens onion and celery, then thickens the milk and cream with a butter-flour roux scented with thyme, giving a hearty, savoury body studded with tender clams. Cullen skink skips the flour: smoked haddock is poached in milk with bay leaf, that infused milk becomes the base, and partly mashed potatoes thicken it, leaving a gentler, smoky soup finished with fresh parsley.

Prep time, calories & servings

Creamy New England Clam Chowder
40 min
A relaxed effort
660 kcal
Feast-worthy
4 servings
Great for the family
Cullen Skink (Traditional Scottish Smoked Haddock Soup)
20 min
Quicker than a pizza delivery
530 kcal
Hearty helping
4 servings
Great for the family

What they have in common

What's different

Only in Creamy New England Clam Chowder
  • Thyme
  • Bacon
  • Clam
  • Herb
  • Celery
Only in Cullen Skink (Traditional Scottish Smoked Haddock Soup)
  • Parsley
  • Bay leaf
  • Smoked haddock

Other counterparts