Skip to content
eatmundo/Compare

Classic St. Louis Gooey Butter Cake vs Traditional Steamed Treacle Sponge Pudding with Custard

See how these two dishes stack up, ingredient by ingredient.

Two questions, two answers

Same ingredients?
63%ingredients in common
Same technique?
Yes
Classic St. Louis Gooey Butter CakeCakeTraditional Steamed Treacle Sponge Pudding with CustardCake

Both desserts lean on butter, sugar, eggs, milk and vanilla, yet they land in very different places. The gooey butter cake is baked: a pressed base of flour, sugar, melted butter and egg sits beneath a rich cream cheese and powdered-sugar layer that turns golden at the edges but stays slightly gooey in the centre. The treacle sponge is steamed instead, its creamed butter-and-sugar batter becoming a soft sponge topped with golden treacle once turned out. Most of its milk and vanilla go into a warm custard thickened with egg yolks and cornflour, served alongside.

Prep time, calories & servings

Classic St. Louis Gooey Butter Cake
40 min
A relaxed effort
380 kcal
Nicely balanced
16 servings
Feeds a crowd
Traditional Steamed Treacle Sponge Pudding with Custard
95 min
A recipe worth the effort
550 kcal
Hearty helping
6 servings
Feeds a crowd

What they have in common

What's different

Only in Classic St. Louis Gooey Butter Cake
  • Cream cheese
  • Powdered sugar
Only in Traditional Steamed Treacle Sponge Pudding with Custard
  • Golden treacle
  • Egg yolk
  • Cornflour
  • Lemon

Other counterparts